Coinfully Reviews
What Real Customers Have To Say About Our Service
249+
4.7/5
93%
A+
Our Ratings Across Every Major Review Platform
4.7 out of 5
4.7 out of 5
A+ Rating
What Our Customers Are Saying
"Coinfully, made my entire experience very easy to liquidate my silver collection. I feel I got a very fair price and they reimbursed for shipping it to them!"
Brian KTrustpilot"I inherited some gold coins from my father's estate and needed to sell them. After reading reviews online, I decided to get an online appraisal from Coinfully and I also took them to a reputable local dealer for a 2nd appraisal. Coinfully appraised my coins at a considerably higher value than the local dealer. Per instructions, I shipped my coins to Coinfully and I had an electronic check in my email the day they received them. The whole process was super easy and stress free and their communication with me at each step of the process was extremely prompt. I have recommended them to my sisters who also inherited coins from our father."
Joseph BTrustpilot"I had a great experience with Coinfully. I inherited a small coin collection and did some online research. Coinfully came up consistently as a good place to do business with. I was skeptical at first, but they proved themselves. They provided a free appraisal, and the process was super-easy."
Beth FGoogle"We couldn't be more grateful for finding Coinfully. We were at a complete loss as to how to successfully liquidate our coins given their location in the USVI. Coinfully came to our house, fully insured everything, and created a detailed inventory of every item. Every step of the process was incredibly professional and easy."
Hannah DTrustpilot"I sent a scan pic of old coin. Same day they made an offer and within 2 days I received an echeck."
Olga CBBB"I had a pile of silver to sell I had bought in the early 2000's and I managed to locate Coinfully by searching on the Internet. He showed up with equipment to process my silver, and when verified, contacted his office to send the money. This was at 3:00 on a Friday afternoon, and by 5:00 the money was in my bank account! The whole experience was very pleasant and professional."
Stephen JTrustpilot"I worked with Braden at Coinfully and was given a very fair price for my collection. It was easy getting the quote, shipping them out and getting paid promptly."
Gregory CGoogle"I highly recommend working with Coinfully. I had several phone calls with various staff members prior to meeting with them. All were pleasant and helpful, leaving me with a strong sense that not only are they professional and knowledgeable but also respectful of my own perspective. Braden was so kind and knowledgeable, shared information and explained the 'why.' Wyatt too was so helpful in this way. They most certainly made the daunting and emotional task of selling a coin collection much less daunting and even enjoyable."
Melissa JTrustpilot"Matt, Braden and Tripp were amazing to work with throughout the entire process! A family member had coins and we were looking for a trustworthy partner to work with. We were extremely impressed with Coinfully and the process from cradle to grave."
Roger HGoogle"My first impression of Coinfully was not the best, and then Wyatt called. Wyatt and Travis are the founding partners at Coinfully and they are Amazing! Wyatt took the time to make sure I was comfortable with Coinfully's business model, and as a new comer to Numismatics he walked me through the process of finding the best value, taking the right pictures, how to safely store the coins I choose to collect, etc."
Sherri MTrustpilot"Everyone (I interacted with Braden and Trip) made the process as 'stress free' as possible. They gave us a very fair and honest appraisal of the collection that was on the higher side of what we expected. Once we agreed, they made the shipping easy too. Payment was also very fast. Personally, I would recommend Coinfully over going to your local coin dealer or attempting to sell your collection on ebay."
ZampardiTrustpilot"I have been waiting 4 years trying to decide when and how to sell inherited gold coins. It seemed impossible to get what I considered a fair price, something at least close to the price of gold. Then the opportunity presented itself and I found Coinfully from an internet search."
Eileen HGoogle"I am not a coin expert, but I know enough to know when I am being taken advantage of. These guys were amazing! They offered a fair price and were super kind when I accidentally left some coins out and added in random ones. They just readjusted the estimate super easily."
Caila LGoogle"Coinfully is phenomenal at what they do. My father got a surprise cancer diagnosis that evolved rapidly, and he was so stressed about what would happen to his beloved coin collection. He had several boxes full of coins he had collected over decades, and all of our local shops asked us to organize everything and lug it into their stores. That's the last thing our family had time for!
Luckily, we found Coinfully, sent in a few pictures, and they agreed to fly out to our house (at their own expense), organize everything themselves, and take it all without us having to lift a finger. Best of all, they gave us an offer that was higher than we believe any of our local shops would have given. My dad felt at peace knowing his collection was in good hands, and that made the whole family breathe easier."Adam ATrustpilot"I inherited a coin collection unexpectedly, and did not know how to exchange it for its cash value. I looked into local appraisers and coin shops but the amount they were willing to pay was disappointing. I was intrigued to find Coinfully that offered to pay a higher rate based on their nationwide approach. From the start they were fast and professional. Their final offer was indeed quite good, and the transaction was quickly done."
Arthur GTrustpilot "Selling my brothers collection was deeply personal. Wyatt was sensitive and respectful. I feel I received an honest and fair appraisal and highly recommend Coinfully."
Mary ATrustpilot"They arrived at my house at 10 AM, set up on my dining table, and proceeded to inventory and catalog all 350 or so coins in my collection. Using standard coin industry guides, they had an appraisal by four o'clock, and funds wired into my bank account by six PM.
They were, as expected, knowledgeable coin professionals and efficient, honest appraisers. I was particularly impressed that they called my attention to two stashes of cash in the pile. And a day after returning to the mainland with the coins, they called me to say they found an error in their totals and were wiring me an additional $17k!"Karl BTrustpilot"Great at home experience with no fear of leaving collection with strangers. Coinfully provided constant communication from initial introduction. Extremely knowledgeable numismatists, two experts arrived on-time to appraise the collection which makes the process go much faster. They come with all the tools to accurately ascertain your coins and can easily weed out any rare or fakes. I was given a check for my estate on-site."
Mitch FTrustpilot "Coinfully was a pleasure to work with. After reaching out to them online, they called and had a personal conversation with me. Based on some pictures that I sent and our conversation, they came to my house to evaluate my collection personally. During the visit, they were very helpful in informing me about my coins and what they were looking at specifically."
Mark ATrustpilot Stories From Real Coinfully Customers
Honesty Is the Best Policy
Dan J
Karl B
From the US Virgin Islands to Full Peace of Mind
My Dad Felt at Peace
Adam A
Tony
65 Years of Coins, One Afternoon of Answers
We Take Every Review Seriously
- We respond to 100% of negative reviews on Trustpilot
- Typical response time: within 24 hours
- When we find errors, we fix them
